News
Leaked EU memo reveals Malta ‘refuses’ to cooperate in migrant rescue missions
Leaked documents from an EU military operation suggest Malta “refuses” to participate in migrant rescue missions in its designated search and rescue area.
An internal memo from the EU’s special naval mission in the Mediterranean, known as IRINI, references what it terms as Malta’s lack of cooperation in migrant rescue operations.
The memo, dated September 2024, was authored by a French legal adviser in the IRINI mission and is intended as a briefing document for French personnel.
It says despite these migrant “events” mainly happening in Malta’s search and rescue zone, it is the Italians who take over as “Malta never responds and refuses to follow these operations”.
The IRINI memo is part of a cache of documents leaked from the European External Action Service, the EU’s diplomatic service.
These documents were obtained by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists and shared with Times of Malta and other media partners. They also detail the perilous journey taken by migrants who pay people smugglers €6,000 for a position on an overcrowded boat from Libya to Malta.
Migrant NGOs have long claimed Malta has a “murderous policy” of failing to uphold its search and rescue obligations at sea.
A spokesperson for AlarmPhone, an NGO that helps facilitate migrant rescues, told Times of Malta that the Maltese authorities seem to cooperate more with Libyan or Tunisian forces to return migrants to “hardship and suffering”.
“These interceptions and returns often take place within Malta’s search and rescue zone… They [Maltese authorities] are very clearly not carrying out rescue operations in the vast majority of cases,” the spokesperson alleged.
While IRINI’s main task is enforcing the UN arms embargo on Libya, one of its secondary goals is disrupting human smuggling and trafficking networks via intelligence gathering and plane patrols over the Mediterranean.
Malta does not form part of the IRINI mission.
Statistics found in the leak indicate Malta rescued 92 migrants between January and October 2024.
In comparison, migrants rescued by the Italian coastguard during the same period stood at 12,399, the Libyan coastguard rescued 8,179 and NGO boats saved 8,271 people.
The Maltese authorities refused a 2022 freedom of information request by Times of Malta for its rescue statistics, citing national security reasons while dismissing the request as “curiosity”.
A spokesperson for the European Commission declined to comment on leaked documents.
The spokesperson said the Commission has a clear position when it comes to search and rescue operations.
“Saving lives at sea is a moral duty, as well as a legal obligation for member states under international law.
“This is done independently from the circumstances which have led people to be in distress at sea,” the spokesperson said.
The spokesperson said all EU countries and all actors involved in search and rescue operations must act in a lawful, swift and coordinated way to make sure that those in distress at sea are brought to safety as rapidly as possible.
In reaction to the memo, a spokesperson for the home affairs ministry told Times of Malta that all emergency notifications received are investigated, assessed, prioritised and acted upon accordingly, regardless of the provenance or legal status of the persons requiring rescue.
The spokesperson said Malta’s responsibility within its search and rescue zone is to coordinate all search and rescue activities using any available resources, not necessarily its own, which may naturally be farther away.
This is done in coordination with neighbouring rescue centres, particularly the one in Rome, with which Malta engages “positively and proactively on a daily basis”, the spokesperson said.
The spokesperson said Malta does not participate in IRINI and any conclusions drawn by third parties, particularly those of a personal nature and not reflecting IRINI’s official position, are made unilaterally and without the involvement of a Maltese counterpart.
The spokesperson said IRINI is a maritime security operation and does not facilitate or coordinate communication between competent rescue centres.
“Malta has no information regarding the basis of third-party conclusions made in internal memos, given that it is not a participant in Operation IRINI, was never consulted on related matters, and that IRINI itself is not a rescue coordination centre,” the spokesperson said.
‘Maltese authorities never reply’
A spokesperson for SOS Méditerranée, which earlier this year rescued more than 100 people from Malta’s search and rescue (SAR) zone, said the Maltese authorities “never reply to our calls or emails”.
She said that while the organisation contacted Malta’s rescue coordination centre (RCC) “straightaway” when learning of a boat in distress, it rarely received a response.
“They rarely pick up the phone, and if they do they tell us to send an e-mail – they never reply to that email. They are really absent from any coordination,” she said.
The spokesperson said that with Malta’s SAR covering a vast territory – stretching from near the Tunisian coast to Greece’s rescue zone – working with other state authorities such as Italy was less common, “but when we do we get more information”.
Asked if the NGO was aware of Malta carrying out rescues, she said: “It’s not happening; what we’re seeing is Libyan boats intercepting in Malta’s SAR against the international maritime convention.”
The spokesperson said such incidents were “no longer surprising”, adding that such moves were “essentially an illegal pushback”.
She noted that while cooperation on rescues was non-existent, medical evacuations from its vessels, while uncommon, were “usually accepted”, however. Seven-year-old Rahf Alhossain, who was airlifted from an SOS Méditerranée rescue boat earlier this year after suffering cardiac arrest, later died at Mater Dei Hospital.
A spokesperson for NGO Alarm Phone, which provides hotline support for boats in distress, said the Maltese authorities “rarely respond on the phone and, if they do, they do not provide any relevant information”.
He said the organisation referred to Malta’s RCC as a “so-called” rescue coordination centre “as they’re clearly not living up to their name”.
Instead, “it seems the focus of the RCC is really to coordinate returns to places like Libya in cooperation with Libyan or Tunisian forces… to return them [migrants] to hardships and suffering”, he said.
“These interceptions and returns often take place within Malta’s search and rescue zone… They [Maltese authorities] are very clearly not carrying out rescue operations in the vast majority of cases.”
Charging Maltese authorities of “systematic forms of non-assistance”, he said their actions made it “much more difficult” to coordinate rescues, adding that “any delay can mean the death of dozens or hundreds of people”.
Meanwhile, a spokesperson for NGO Sea-Watch, which operates spotter aircraft and rescue vessels in the Mediterranean, said: “Malta does not cooperate with us; if they do pick up the phone, they ignore the information we give them.”
The spokesperson said that most calls from its spotter aircraft went unanswered, adding Malta’s rescue coordination centre had told the NGO over the phone in the past: “We don’t work with NGOs.”
The spokesperson noted Malta had in the past attended migrant boats in distress only to provide fuel and supplies to enable them to proceed to other states’ rescue zones or territorial waters.
In January, rescue NGO Sea Punks said that despite “multiple attempts” to contact Maltese authorities about a fibreglass boat in Malta’s SAR with 41 people on board, including five women and six children, it had received no response.
Source: timesofmalta.com
News
New rescue vessel Aurora 2: Sea-Watch’s response to political blockades of civilian sea rescue
Sea-Watch is putting a new rescue vessel into service: With the Aurora 2, the organization is responding to the repeated detentions of civilian rescue ships by the Italian authorities. Now, Sea-Watch will remain operational even when one of its ships is detained. While one ship is blocked in port, the other will be available to carry out rescue missions. The far-right government’s strategy of limiting rescue operations through arbitrary detentions has therefore failed.
Julia Winkler, spokesperson for the organization Sea-Watch:
“Italy is detaining rescue ships to stop people from being rescued. With the Aurora 2, we are making sure this strategy fails. If one of our vessels is detained, the other will be ready to save lives. By expanding our fleet, we are fighting back against the far-right Italian government’s efforts to obstruct civilian search and rescue at sea.”
In the Mediterranean, speed is a matter of life and death. Every distress case is a race against time. That is why Sea-Watch operates not only the large vessel Sea-Watch 5 but also a smaller, faster ship—the Aurora. The Aurora reaches top speeds of up to 25 knots, allowing it to quickly reach people in distress at sea. With the Aurora 2, the organization is now specifically expanding its operational capabilities.
The acquisition of the Aurora 2 is a direct response to the far-right Italian government’s policy of systematically detaining civilian rescue ships. Since 2023, the Meloni cabinet has detained civilian sea rescue ships in port more than forty times. As a result, the entire civilian fleet has lost more than 900 days of operational time. The Aurora has also been blocked five times already. Italian courts subsequently overturned the rulings on several occasions. However, by the time the respective court decisions were issued, the Aurora had lost a total of 113 days of operational time.
With the Aurora 2, Sea-Watch is specifically countering this strategy. If one of the ships is detained, the other can continue to set sail and rescue people in distress at sea. In this way, the organization ensures its independence from bureaucratic blockades and guarantees the continuation of its rescue operations.
The detentions of civil search and rescue vessels are politically motivated and cost lives. The Mediterranean is one of the deadliest borders in the world. More than 34,000 people have been reported dead or missing since 2014. The actual number is estimated to be significantly higher. With its new ship, the Aurora 2, Sea-Watch can continue to quickly rescue people from drowning — even if one of its ships is blocked by the far-right Italian government.
Sea-Watch is part of the Justice Fleet, an alliance whose members are committed to upholding human rights and international maritime law. Its members refuse to comply with instructions provided for in the so-called Piantedosi Decree that conflict with international law and human rights obligations and are primarily intended to hinder rescue operations. As a result, their vessels are regularly detained by the Italian authorities. In recent months, Italian courts have overturned detention orders imposed on several Justice Fleet vessels in summary proceedings. Rulings on the overall legality of the Decree are still pending.
News
Sea-Watch strongly criticises EU response following attack on Sea-Watch 5

In response to the attack on the Sea-Watch 5 on Monday, 11 May 2026, the European Commission stated at its press conference on Wednesday, 12 May 2026, that EU cooperation with Libyan actors “prevented further violence.” Sea-Watch condemns this portrayal as a grotesque distortion of reality. Without the political, financial, and operational support of the EU, the so-called Libyan coast guard would neither possess boats nor the necessary infrastructure to operate at sea.
Julia Winkler, spokesperson for Sea-Watch:
“The EU has been working closely with actors in Libya for years, who are accused of committing the most serious crimes against people on the move, equipping them and enabling their operations at sea. Against this background, claiming that this very cooperation prevents violence is an absurd distortion of reality and is nothing short of cynical.”
A Commission spokesperson responded to questions regarding the violent attack on the Sea-Watch 5 on Monday, 11 May 2026, stating that it cannot be determined how many further attacks may have been prevented precisely due to consistent engagement (from 4:39). After the crew had rescued people in distress in international waters, Libyan militias opened fire and threatened to forcibly return the ship and those on board to Libya.
The attackers identified themselves as so-called Libyan Coast Guard. During the attack, the vessel involved was accompanied by the Murzuq 662 – a Bigliani-class ship handed over by Italy in June 2023 to Libyan actors as part of the EU–Libya cooperation framework SIBMMIL. Later the same day, the Sea-Watch 5 was also followed by the Ras Jadir 648, another vessel transferred by Italy to Libyan actors in May 2017.
Despite mayday calls being issued, neither Germany nor Italy, nor the EU naval mission EUNAVFOR MED IRINI provided assistance at sea on the day of the attack. On the contrary, on the same day the EU emphasised its intentions to expand cooperation and funding for Libyan actors in eastern Libya. These groups have been documented for years as responsible for torture, sexual violence, and kidnappings of people on the move. Without European support, such structures would not be operational in their current form.
For years, Sea-Watch and international organisations, including the United Nations, have documented serious human rights violations by Libyan militias and coast guard units with which they are closely linked. The political and legal responsibility of European actors is subject to ongoing international legal scrutiny. In 2022, the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights filed a criminal complaint against senior representatives of the EU and its Member States for alleged crimes against humanity in connection with the EU–Libya cooperation.
News
Court annuls 20-day administrative detention imposed on Ocean Viking
SOS MEDITERRANEE has welcomed the recent decision of the Court of Chieti in Italy, which fully annuls the 20-day administrative detention imposed on the Ocean Viking in November 2023, together with the related fine and all associated sanctioning measures.
On 15 November 2023, Italian authorities detained the Ocean Viking in Ortona for 20 days and imposed a financial penalty under Decree Law No. 1/2023, known as the “Piantedosi Decree”. The case relates to a rescue operation conducted on 11 November 2023 in the Libyan Search and Rescue Region, during which our rescue ship rescued 34 people from a boat in distress after repeated unsuccessful attempts to obtain effective coordination from the Libyan maritime authorities.
In its first instance decision, the Court clearly confirmed that the Ocean Viking’s rescue operation was lawful, and that the captain “was faced with the necessity to intervene without delay” to protect human life. It also underscored the absence of effective coordination by the Libyan authorities, recognizing that the Ocean Viking was “the only vessel to intervene” to fulfill the duty to rescue at sea.
The judgment also reaffirmed that international maritime obligations under the UNCLOS, SOLAS and SAR Conventions prevail when human lives are at risk, and that sanctions cannot be imposed where state coordination is absent or inadequate. The decision recalls the Italian Constitutional Court’s ruling n°101/2025, which confirmed that national laws on sea rescue must comply with international law. In other words, no national law can be in contrast with the duty of saving lives at sea.
“This ruling confirms what we have consistently stated since November 2023: the Ocean Viking acted in full compliance with international maritime law and in the clear fulfilment of its maritime obligations,” said Soazic Dupuy, Director of Operations at SOS MEDITERRANEE. “Humanitarian rescue organisations must never be penalised for doing what authorities fail to do: ensuring timely and effective rescue for people in distress.” she concludes.
2026 is already among the deadliest years of the last decade. People continue to go missing at sea while the Italian government doubles down on efforts to prevent Search and Rescue NGOs from operating. This week, the Senate began discussing a new migration package that includes Provisions aimed at preventing Search and Rescue NGOs from entering Italian waters, yet another attempt to obstruct lifesaving operations.
On Saturday 16th, the captain of the Sea-Watch 5 was accused of facilitating irregular migration after completing a rescue operation following which the Libyan Coast Guard opened fire.
Despite repeated court rulings confirming the legality of civil rescue operations, Search and Rescue NGOs continue to face legal and administrative harassment for saving lives at sea. People in distress cannot wait for justice while lifesaving assistance is obstructed for political purposes.
-
News7 days agoWar has devastated life for millions of refugees, displaced
-
Features7 days agoNetherlands, IOM reaffirm partnership including new multi-year funding commitment
-
Features7 days agoStabilization gains open pathway to development in Central African Republic: IOM Chief of Staff
-
News Extra7 days agoWest and Central Africa urges more climate funding as displacement rises
-
News Extra7 days agoDiaspora remittances point to untapped potential in crisis response: New IOM report
-
Features2 days agoEbola: Border closures alone risk driving movement underground and increasing transmission risks
-
News Extra3 days agoNigeria leads Liberia, Ghana, others as US set to deport migrants
-
Features3 days agoHaiti hosts over 1million displaced persons
