News
Detention order: MSF Sea refutes Italian authorities’ allegations
MSF Sea has refuted Italian authorities’ allegations leading to a detention order slammed on its rescue ship, GeoBarents.
On 26 August 2024, the Italian authorities have issued a 60-day detention order to the Geo Barents, a search and rescue ship operated by Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Borders (MSF), for alleged violations of maritime safety regulations.
The detention order was issued following several rescue operations that took place very early morning of 23 August in the Central Mediterranean, where the Geo Barents is alleged to have failed to provide timely information to the Italian Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre (MRCC) and to have endangered people’s lives. MSF refutes these allegations, which are based on information provided by the Libyan Coast Guard.
“The EU-supported Libyan Coast Guard who the Italian authorities consider as a reliable actor, has been documented and accused by the United Nations of complicity in serious human rights violations in Libya, amounting to crimes against humanity, collusion with smugglers and traffickers and of being responsible for violent pushbacks at sea” says Juan Matias Gil, MSF search and rescue representative. “We have been sanctioned for simply fulfilling our legal duty to save lives.”
On that day, MSF teams on Geo Barents conducted five rescue operations. The third operation, in which MSF is accused of failing to provide timely information about, occurred after our team witnessed a significant number of people going overboard in the vicinity of the ship. “It was in the middle of the night; we saw people jumping off a fibreglass boat, falling or being pushed into the water. Our teams had no choice than to go, stabilise people and retrieve them out of water as quickly as possible” says Riccardo Gatti, MSF Search and Rescue Team Leader. “There was an imminent danger of people drowning or getting lost in the darkness of the night.”
This is significant not only because it is the third time the Geo Barents has been detained, but also because it’s for the longest period. So far, it’s the twenty-third occasion on which a humanitarian rescue ship has been detained since the enforcement of Italian decree-law in early 2023, known as ‘Piantedosi Decree’. The decree-law which is specifically designed to impede the vital search and rescue activities of non-governmental organisations (NGOs) at sea.
“It was in the middle of the night; we saw people jumping off a fibreglass boat, falling or being pushed into the water. Our teams had no choice than to go, stabilise people and retrieve them out of water as quickly as possible”Riccardo Gatti, MSF Search and Rescue Team Leader.
“This is yet another example of how much the Piantedosi Decree not only contravenes international and European laws but is also contradictory to the obligations to act in the face of a state of necessity when human lives are at risk,” states Gil. “The authorities are forcing us to prioritise either saving people at sea or the freedom of the rescue ship. The preservation of human life is at the core of our MSF’s social mission, and we will therefore be contesting this unlawful detention through the appropriate legal channels”.
The Geo Barents is currently unable to conduct rescues in the Mediterranean due to the aforementioned detention. This will further exacerbate the already insufficient search and rescue capacity at sea, making the Central Mediterranean – one of the world’s most dangerous migration routes – even more deadly.
MSF urges the Italian authorities to release the Geo Barents from this detention to fulfil its duty of rescuing lives and cease immediately obstructing humanitarian lifesaving assistance at sea. We also call on the EU and its member states to suspend all material and financial support to the Libyan Coast Guard and authorities with a track record of human rights violations.
Background information
On 23 August 2024, MSF teams conducted five different rescue operations in the Central Mediterranean Sea. In total, 191 people were rescued, including women and children. Afterwards, the Italian MRCC first assigned Napoli as the place of safety (POS) to disembark people, and this was later changed to the port of Civitavecchia, and then, to Salerno.
MSF has been active in search and rescue activities since 2015, working on eight different rescue vessels (alone or in partnership with other NGOs) and having rescued more than 91,000 people. Since launching search and rescue operations on board Geo Barents in May 2021, MSF teams have rescued more than 12,300 people, recovered the bodies of 24 people, arranged for medical evacuation of 4 people and assisted in the delivery of one baby.
—
News
ICC confirmation of 17 charges against El-Hishri draws praise from rights groups
Human rights organisations and migrant rights advocates have welcomed the International Criminal Court’s (ICC) decision to confirm all 17 charges against Osama El-Hishri, describing it as a landmark step towards justice for victims of abuses committed at Libya’s notorious Mitiga Prison.
The ICC’s confirmation of the charges clears the way for El-Hishri to stand trial over allegations linked to murder, torture, sexual violence and other crimes allegedly committed against detainees at the prison in Tripoli.
Reacting to the decision, migrant distress network Alarm Phone described the ruling as “historic” for survivors of crimes committed at Mitiga Prison.
“The International Criminal Court confirmed all 17 charges against El-Hishri. This is a historic decision for survivors of crimes committed at Mitiga prison in Libya,” the organisation said in a statement posted on X.
Alarm Phone also echoed calls by refugee advocacy group Refugees in Libya, saying the prosecution should mark the beginning of broader efforts to hold perpetrators of abuses in Libya accountable.
Similarly, Sea-Watch International hailed the ICC’s decision, noting that the confirmation means the case will now proceed to trial.
The organisation alleged that El-Hishri was a senior member of Libya’s Special Deterrence Force (SDF/RADA) militia and headed parts of Mitiga Prison, where migrants and refugees were subjected to severe human rights violations.
“The ICC confirmed all 17 charges against El-Hishri today. The case is going to trial,” Sea-Watch International said.
It added that people on the move detained at Mitiga Prison had been subjected to murder, torture and sexual violence, describing the prosecution as an important step in addressing longstanding impunity for abuses against migrants in Libya.
Activist Yousef Ismail also welcomed the court’s decision, saying it represented the kind of justice victims had long demanded.
“This is the real number; this is the truth we seek. We always speak of justice and respect for human rights. The International Criminal Court has fairly proven 17 charges against the so-called ‘Hashri,’ the rapist and the gatekeeper of Mitiga,” he wrote on X.
The ICC’s decision has been widely viewed by rights advocates as a significant milestone in efforts to secure accountability for crimes allegedly committed against migrants and refugees held in Libya’s detention system.
Campaigners, however, stressed that the prosecution of El-Hishri should not be the end of international efforts, urging authorities to investigate other individuals allegedly responsible for serious human rights violations in Libya’s detention facilities.
News
Expert raises questions over UNHCR’s strategic direction after new leadership appointments
A former Head of Policy Development and Evaluation at the UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR), Jeff Crisp, has suggested that the organization’s newly announced leadership appointments could signal a shift in its priorities away from refugee protection and asylum toward humanitarian assistance and development.
Reacting to the appointments in a post on X, Crisp said the selection of the agency’s new senior officials “suggest that the agency might be going to focus on humanitarian assistance & development issues rather than refugee protection & asylum.”
He added that his concerns were reinforced by UNHCR’s support for the European Union’s Pact on Migration and Asylum.
“A suspicion strengthened by UNHCR’s endorsement of the EU Pact on Migration & Asylum,” Crisp wrote.
His comments came shortly after United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres announced the appointments of Tressa Rae Finerty as Deputy High Commissioner for Refugees, Antón Leis García as Assistant High Commissioner for Operations, and Edem Wosornu as Assistant High Commissioner for Protection.
UN High Commissioner for Refugees Barham Salih welcomed the appointments, saying the three officials bring extensive experience in humanitarian affairs, international cooperation and refugee protection. They are expected to assume their duties in the coming weeks.
Crisp’s remarks reflect concerns held by some refugee rights advocates and migration experts who have argued that UNHCR faces increasing pressure to balance its traditional mandate of protecting refugees and defending the right to asylum with expanding responsibilities in humanitarian response, development cooperation and migration management.
The appointments come at a time when the agency is grappling with record levels of forced displacement worldwide, shrinking humanitarian funding and increasingly restrictive asylum policies in many parts of the world.
News
Conflict, displacement fuel Ebola outbreak in Eastern DR Congo, NRC warns
The Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC) has warned that the ongoing Bundibugyo Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) is spreading in communities already devastated by years of armed conflict, displacement and inadequate access to basic services, urging the international community to step up funding and political support for the response.
In a statement, NRC’s Country Director in DR Congo, Eric Batonon, said the outbreak was unfolding in Ituri province, the current epicentre of the epidemic, where thousands of displaced people have spent years living in overcrowded shelters with poor sanitation and limited healthcare.
According to Batonon, prolonged violence by armed groups competing for control of land and mineral resources has forced millions from their homes, while the humanitarian crisis has received insufficient attention from donors and the international community.
He said these conditions had created an environment in which Ebola has been able to spread rapidly, contributing to the rising number of infections.
Batonon stressed that infection prevention and control measures must remain central to the response, adding that affected communities should play a leading role in shaping response strategies.
He said building trust and engaging directly with local populations would be critical to containing the outbreak, arguing that Ebola can only be effectively controlled when community priorities guide public health policies.
The NRC said it has intensified its Ebola response in eastern DRC through community awareness campaigns and preventive health measures. The organisation is establishing handwashing stations, distributing hygiene supplies and supporting efforts to reduce the risk of infection in affected communities.
It also said its teams are working to minimise disruptions to children’s education by helping schools operate safely during the outbreak.
In addition, NRC staff are assessing the impact of the epidemic on internally displaced persons in Ituri as well as neighbouring North and South Kivu provinces, where many people continue to live in overcrowded camps with inadequate sanitation facilities.
The findings, Batonon said, will help shape humanitarian interventions for some of the country’s most vulnerable populations.
The NRC noted that DR Congo has appeared on its annual list of the world’s most neglected displacement crises every year over the past decade, reflecting what it described as persistent international neglect of the humanitarian situation in the country’s east.
Batonon called on donors to provide flexible and sustained funding while increasing political engagement to ensure the Ebola response can outpace the spread of the disease and address the underlying humanitarian conditions that have worsened the outbreak.
-
News2 weeks agoFavour Henshaw appointed administrator of Platform for Cooperation on Mixed Migration
-
News3 weeks agoFormer UNHCR official sparks debate with ‘there is no such thing as a race’ comment
-
News2 weeks agoLampedusa: built to accommodate 400 people, now holds thousands of migrants
-
News Extra2 weeks agoPope urges European leaders to make greater investment in developing migrants’ countries of origin
-
News6 days agoIYAMIDR commends Okpebholo for ₦1m support to South Africa returnees
-
Features3 weeks ago1,500 young Chadians to benefit from EU, IOM funds
-
News2 weeks agoWorld silent as drone strikes, extreme hunger ravage El Obeid families
-
Features2 weeks agoLampedusa: Pope’s visit powerful reaffirmation migrants, refugees must remain at centre of global efforts
